For many content marketers, SEO tools are just like superheroes. Not only because they’ve changed our world forever, but because we can’t live without the ongoing debate about who’s the best. Some of us are all about Iron Man’s fancy gadgets, while others lean more toward Superman’s raw power and heat vision.
It’s the same for SEO professionals: Some prefer the meticulous, technical prowess of Screaming Frog SEO Spider, while others swear by the all-seeing, competitive insights of Ahrefs. But what if you’re stuck in the middle, undecidedly looking to both heroes in the hope of rescue? Fear not! This article is here to help you understand which tool can save the day for your SEO tasks — whether you’re crawling every nook and cranny of your HTTP header or spying on your competition’s keyword arsenal.
Key Features That Make Screaming Frog SEO Spider and Ahrefs Stand Out
Welcome to the search engine marketing arena, where we figure out what unique strengths and weaknesses our two contenders have.
Screaming Frog SEO Spider: The Techie’s Sidekick
Think of Screaming Frog as Batman’s utility belt — packed with precise, customizable tools. It’s all about the nitty-gritty details of your site. As a desktop-based application, Screaming Frog gives you full control over the crawling process. You can fine-tune your settings, making sure every little URL, image and meta tag is scrutinized.
For all its strengths in technical SEO, Screaming Frog doesn’t stretch into the world of competitive analysis or backlink research. So, while it’s great for fixing technical issues, you won’t find any tools for keeping an eye on your industry here.
Ahrefs: The All-Powerful Visionary
Now, Ahrefs is like Superman — powerful, versatile and full of surprises helping you to take on any challenge, just with a little less finesse in the technical department. Ahrefs is web-based, meaning you can access it from anywhere, and it focuses heavily on competitive analysis and backlink research.
While it does let you dive into your competitors’ strategies, track your keyword rankings and discover backlink opportunities, the web-based interface also means you won’t be able to render any JavaScript-heavy pages here.
Let’s compare their unique strengths in a bit more detail.
Subscribe to
The Content Marketer
Get weekly insights, advice and opinions about all things digital marketing.
Thanks for subscribing! Keep an eye out for a Welcome email from us shortly. If you don’t see it come through, check your spam folder and mark the email as “not spam.”
Ahrefs’ and Screaming Frog’s Unique Features in Comparison
| Category | Screaming Frog | Ahrefs |
| Primary function | Desktop-based website crawler for in-depth technical SEO audits (Windows, macOS and Linux). | Comprehensive web-based SEO toolset for backlink analysis, keyword research and competitor insights. |
| Technical SEO audits | Detailed site crawling to identify broken links, server errors and redirects.Analyzes page titles, meta data, headers, images and duplicate content.JavaScript rendering to analyze dynamic content. | Site audit tool to identify common technical issues.Provides health score and prioritizes issues, but doesn’t show in-depth analyses of tags or duplicate content.Limited in-depth crawling capabilities. |
| Backlink analysis | Limited backlink analysis capabilities. | Extensive backlink analysis with one of the largest live backlink indexes.Detailed backlink metrics like Domain Rating (DR) and URL Rating (UR). |
| Keyword research | N/A | Comprehensive Keyword Explorer tool covering multiple search engines.Provides keyword difficulty scores, search volume and click metrics. |
| Competitor analysis | N/A | Site Explorer for analyzing competitors’ organic search traffic and backlink profiles.Content Gap analysis to find keywords competitors rank for but you don’t. |
| Custom data extraction | Extracts custom data using XPath, CSSPath or Regex. | N/A |
| API integrations | Integrates with Google Analytics, Search Console, Majestic, Ahrefs, Moz and PageSpeed Insights for enriched data.Integrates with ChatGPT through its custom JavaScript feature to leverage preset snippets during crawls. | Integrates with over 20 data sources focused on backlinks and keywords, including Screamingfrog SEO Spider, Netpeak Checker, Spamzilla, BuzzStream and Google Sheets. |
| Crawl configuration | Extensive options for configuring crawl settings, including user-agent customization and robots.txt handling. | No customizable crawl, but Ahrefs Webmaster Tools can give you a sense of the database. |
| XML sitemap generation | Generates XML sitemaps with advanced configuration options. | N/A |
| Content research | N/A | Content Explorer to discover top-performing content in any niche.Analyzes content performance based on social shares and backlinks. |
| Rank tracking | N/A | Rank Tracker to monitor keyword rankings over time across multiple locations. |
| Alerts and notifications | N/A | Set up alerts for new or lost backlinks, keyword rankings and web mentions. |
| SERP analysis | N/A | Analyze SERP features with historical SERP data to understand ranking fluctuations. |
| User interface | Desktop application with a data-rich interface; may have a steeper learning curve for beginners. | Web-based platform with a user-friendly interface and intuitive data visualizations. |
| Free version availability | Free version available (crawls up to 500 URLs). | No free version; offers trial with limited features. |
| Pricing model | Annual license fee of $259 for the paid version. | Subscription-based pricing with various plans suited for individuals and enterprises, starting at $129. |
Keyword Research Use Case Scenarios
As you can tell by looking at the table above, there are not too many categories where the two tools are truly comparable. That’s not because one’s “better,” but because one’s playing chess and the other tennis (we’ll let you guess which one’s which).
One area where they do slightly overlap is keyword research, even though they approach it from different angles. So let’s look at how each tool shines.
Best for Technical Site Audits: Screaming Frog
When it comes to conducting a deep dive into your site’s health, Screaming Frog excels. It’s perfect for users looking under the hood to do detailed technical SEO audits, especially those focusing on site structure and issues like broken links, missing meta tags or duplicate content. Its crawl depth and customization options allow for granular insights into your website’s performance, making it ideal for troubleshooting issues that could affect your keyword rankings.
Screaming Frog also helps in uncovering underlying technical problems that could hinder your site’s SEO performance, which in turn impacts keyword optimization. If your goal is to ensure your site is clean and optimized for search engines, this tool is a critical first step.
Best for Competitive Analysis: Ahrefs
On the flip side, if you’re looking to analyze the competition and identify the keywords they’re ranking for, Ahrefs is your go-to. Ahrefs provides powerful backlink analysis, keyword gap tools and insights into the organic traffic that your competitors are driving. With its Keyword Explorer and Site Explorer features, you can uncover keywords that your competitors are targeting, track their keyword rankings and even see which content types are bringing in the most traffic.
Ahrefs also helps you identify keyword opportunities by showing you gaps — terms your competitors rank for but you don’t. It’s an invaluable tool if you’re crafting a strategy based on competitive insights and want to stay one step ahead in the keyword game.
Ideal Scenarios for Combined Use
While both tools are powerful on their own, there are scenarios where using both in tandem can provide extra value. For instance, you could use Screaming Frog for an initial site audit to clean up any technical SEO issues — such as fixing broken links or ensuring your metadata is on point — and then switch to Ahrefs for continuous monitoring of your keyword rankings, backlink profile and competitor research.
This combined approach ensures that your site remains healthy and competitive in the long run, with Screaming Frog handling the technical side and Ahrefs tracking your ongoing SEO performance and competitive landscape.
Pricing and Plans for Both SEO Tools
Screaming Frog and Ahrefs take very different approaches to pricing, each suited to its ideal user. Screaming Frog’s one-time license fee is a practical choice for technical SEOs or website owners focused on periodic site audits, especially with the free version available for smaller projects. It’s perfect for users who need in-depth, customizable crawls without an ongoing subscription.
Ahrefs, meanwhile, is tailored for those who need constant access to competitive data, rank tracking and keyword insights. With its subscription plans starting at $129 per month, Ahrefs is a smart investment for SEOs, agencies and businesses focused on staying competitive through continuous monitoring and keyword strategy.
In the end, choosing between Screaming Frog and Ahrefs comes down to your specific SEO needs. Whether you’re all about perfecting your site’s technical health or keeping a close watch on the competition, both tools offer powerful, distinct advantages. Armed with this guide, you’ll be ready to select the right sidekick to conquer your SEO goals.
